CASE BRIEFING ~ GRAZING ALLOTMENTS ON THE TUSHAR MOUNTAIN RANGE, FISHLAKE NATIONAL FOREST, UTAH
Agreement Reached on Grazing Recommendations on the Fishlake National Forest
For the past two years, the Grand Canyon Trust and Utah Farm Bureau have cosponsored an effort to resolve
outstanding disputes related to two of eight cattle grazing allotments on the Tushar Mountain Range in the
Beaver Ranger District, Fishlake National Forest, Utah. In March 2009, the USDA Forest Service, permittees,
representatives of environmental groups, and other interested parties reached agreement on revisions to
the Ten Mile and Pine Creek/Sulphurbeds Allotments.
In March 2007, representatives from several environmental organizations agreed to withdraw an administrative
appeal in favor of a collaborative process to develop overall management recommendations for the two grazing
allotments. The collaboration addressed natural resource conditions and livestock management, including but
not limited to aspen and mountain mahogany conservation and restoration on both allotments, and a plan for
reestablishment of suitable habitat for beaver on Pine Creek within the Pine Creek/Sulphurbeds Allotment.
The collaborative effort was formally convened and facilitated by the U.S. Institute for Environmental Conflict
Resolution. The U.S. Institute provided general guidance and facilitation assistance through a third-party
neutral, Michele Straube, of Salt Lake City.
"This is an encouraging case where grazing and environmental interests were able to work together successfully,
with strong support from the Forest Service, to resolve disputes over natural resource conditions and grazing
management on public lands," said Larry Fisher, senior program manager at the U.S. Institute.
The parties have been meeting regularly since April 2007, conducting periodic field visits and monitoring work,
and negotiating initial draft documents to determine the current conditions of the two allotments. Based on
these discussions and the monitoring data they have collected together, the parties identified desired
conditions that will be considered by the Forest Service in developing revised Allotment Management Plans.
A final report will soon be circulated and posted on the project Web site at
http://tushar.ecr.gov. Some details remain to be worked out among the
permittees. While regular meetings of the Collaboration have been completed, much remains to be done in
finalizing plans for the two allotments, and in implementing these agreed-upon changes. The Collaboration
is scheduled to meet again in January 2010 and 2011 to review implementation during the previous years.
For additional information about this agreement, please visit www.ecr.gov or
contact Larry Fisher at fisher@ecr.gov or 520.901.8501.